Question of a Song.   
Jul,13,2008
 

Thank you folks for the response to Imran and Genelia. They are absolutely thrilled.

Have a very unusual question for you.

You see we had two more songs in the film, one is the female version of Jaane Tu Mera Kya Hai, Jaane Tu Mera Kya ThaÖ sung by Runa , and the other is the male version of the same song sung by Sukhvinder. Both songs had been shot. In the test screenings we decided to cut out the male version because we felt it stopped the flow of the story. However opinion on the female version was divided. Through all the test screenings and the final edit we were not sure whether to cut that song out or retain it in the film. Sometimes we would remove it, then we would put it back in. A.R., if I remember correctly, wanted it to stay in. We finally decided to complete the final copy (first print) with the song in it. We figured we would see the final film and then take a final call whether to keep it or cut it out.

The music had released by then so the music CDs and cassettes have the songs in it. The music company was strongly in favor of keeping the female version song in the film. As per their feedback the song had become quite popular. Around the 2nd week of June with less than a month left for the release our final copy was finally ready. We saw the film and had a long discussion again about the song. About 40 to 50 people were at that screening, again the opinion was divided. However Abbas, Mansoor and I were of the opinion that we should go without it. We felt it didnít fit in with the rest of the movie. So we cut the song out and what we have released is what we think the movie should be.

Am always curious about such decisions. The movie has been loved so I am assuming we took the right decision. But a number of people have also come up to me and said that they had liked the song in the audio and missed it in the film.

Want your opinion.

Should it have been in the film? Do you think we should add the song into the film now? The song is ready and its easy enough for me to do...

 
Posted by Aamir Khan at 10:08 PM
 
2065 Comments  Post Comment Aamir's Responses
 
 
2065 Comments
 
2035. nikiforu
Posted on Aug,27,2008 at 02:39 AM
the song is amazing...i love it !
i heard it just recently n find the singers voice too
appealing...! bt i dont think any need for it to b in the
movie......it has enough songs

 
2034. SonaliBasu
Posted on Aug,25,2008 at 03:33 PM
May i begin by saying that i absolutely love the song(s),
especially the male version by Sukhwinder. I am not the expert
here, but I am a little surprised that the production team
considered the female version more desirable or worth
consideration than the male version. Of course, I must rush to
add that this is my very personal opinion. In any case, I , for
one , feel that any version, would have added to the film, though
my personal favourite would still be Jai's version!

 
2033. manyu4abhi
Posted on Aug,25,2008 at 02:34 PM
the song is nice but it should not b in the movie....

 
2032. sachi11
Posted on Aug,24,2008 at 08:22 PM
Ya...surely....

 
2031. neeraj_jai
Posted on Aug,24,2008 at 12:49 AM
HI!

Im a big fan of u, imran, and aamir

I ABSOLUTELY LOVED THE MOVIE

please put the DVD out soon...

Also... if it wouldnt be too much too ask

could you please ask rahman ji to put out a karaoke version of
all the songs in the movie

and im sure many others would like this
as we will be able to hum along to the amazing songs

OTHER MEMBERS please request also....

thanks....
neeraj

 
2030. everywhereatatime
Posted on Aug,21,2008 at 09:29 PM
i have seen the female version, and heard it :)

its got a lot of emotion in it, in the right quantity. and i
believe that it's already in the theatres.

but the movie has very beautifully used a language throughout
that the youth of india use while they talk. including the songs
in the film. very metro and young :)

this one however, though it conveys all aditi feels, it doesn't
sound like something aditi would say. not like that.

:p

i looooooooooooooved the movie. genelia showed us everything
aditi was feeling. i feel we don't need a song for that :)

 
2029. qamar
Posted on Aug,21,2008 at 06:48 PM
hi aamir
i am new 2 ur blog........ aswell as 2 ur fanlist..i want to get
close and personel to u sir...i had become a fan of urs after
TZP....and after JTYJN i am a hiehard fan of urs..

 
2028. prateekbri
Posted on Aug,19,2008 at 04:03 PM
hey hi amir,
i liked the jane tu...... female version very
much..................................

 
2027. nillaan
Posted on Aug,17,2008 at 08:41 PM
hi amir i am nillaan hey u should put that song and advance
ramadan mubarak i wish to chat with u

 
2026. shreya11232001
Posted on Aug,16,2008 at 12:32 PM
Hii aamir ...... juss relax ...... We liked the muvee as it was
........ !!!!!! .... No need to Scratch ur head over it ..... The
muvee was awsum ......!!!!! .......

 
 
[Start] << 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | >> [End]
Total Pages: 207  |  Go to page:
 
 
 
 

 
Login
 
Login ID :
Password:
   
 
Sign Up Forgot Password
 
Write your feedback
 

 
Blog Archives
DB music is out now.
Producer's Note, Delhi Belly.
Happy Diwali.
Waltz With Bashir!
TIFF
Happy Independence Day!
FB Live Chat tonight.
The butterflies are waking up!
Tell me.
Mad times are here again.
SSC Results.
Special dinner.
Numb.
Tragic.
Lets live healthy.
Dom Cathedral.
Paris and London.
Paris.
Thank you for your support.
Time out.
Live from Sundance.
Thank you Ahmedabad.
Thank you Bangalore, hello Kolkata.
D DAY!!!
Andheri kaali raat...
Catch me if you can!!!
Good news.
Round the clock.
Hai hai yeh majboori...
Announcement for Live Chat!!!
First look of 3i.
Happy Dipawali
Deadline time.
Withnail, Ignatius and I.
S Redemption.
Mind It.
I will be away for a while.
Dark side of the moon.
Attack of the Sandman.
Sandman seems to have been very liberal with his sand.
The Sandman has struck...
Sorry.
:-(
Do Or Die!
And finally the Rolland Garros.
Back To Work.
DELIRIUM DIVE!
Summer Holidays!
Oops.
Happy Birthday to me. :-)
Lang Langed!
Jai Ho!
Thank you.
Yes Ghajini is Releasing.
A belated Eid Mubarak.
From the ashes rises the Phoenix.
SHOCKED, HEARTBROKEN, HELPLESS, ANGRY.
Homeward bound.
Sleepless In Seattle.
Happy Diwali.
Ant Attack.
Hello.
Glorious moment.
Two bits of good news and one bad.
Itís a bird... itís a plane... Abbas Tyrewala
ONE WEEK EXPERIMENT.
Genelia and Imran.
Thank you.
D Day!
Hectic!
Confession time.
Sachin the great.
Settlers Of Panchgani.
Serves me right!!!
Ru-ba-ru.
Alive but not kicking.
Olympic Torch Relay.
Heading home.
Its finally off my head!
Thanks guys. Much appreciated.
WORLD CHAMPIONS!!!
GHAJINI resumes.
The washer and dryer effect.
Darsheel's words.
EID MUBARAK and MERRY CHRISTMAS from CLOUD 9!!!
Reactions.
DONE!!!
Thanks for the drubbing on my smoking.
Overworked and stressed.
HAPPY DIWALI.
Petrified!!!
Time to move on.
Trying to resurface.
Seasons Greetings.
Keeping y'all posted.
EID MUBARAK.
Change in plans.
reached.
another 15 mts.
Still on my way.
Technical trouble.
Welcome.
Lagaandvd Blogs
Goodbye. Last post.
I'm alive, I'm alive!!!
A quick hello.
Apologies
Shame.
Uncomfortably numb, actually.
At last.
NO! NO! NO!
Whew.
TOMORROW.
In transit... to the next topic.
City Of Djinns
Pictures ... at the Recording Studio ...
Mostly responses
Bangalore.
Just to say hi.
Of Federer. fans, FANAA and films.
Wimbledon
Its Memento not Momento!!!
GHAJINI.
28 June 2007
26th June 07.
Creating Bhuvan.
Do I need to give a title each time?
Refreshing
Chale Chalo clip.
Great to know.
First step. AAMIR.